Reviewer's Responsibilities
A Trust-Based Role Rooted in Academic Responsibility, Fairness, and Professional Judgment
Thoughtful Evaluation
As a reviewer, your role extends beyond approval or critique—it is a contribution to the advancement of science. We encourage you to engage with each manuscript with care, curiosity, and a genuine intention to help improve its clarity, rigor, and relevance. Consider the originality of the research, the strength of its methodology, and the integrity of its results. Offer your perspective with confidence, but also with humility and openness.
Constructive and Respectful Tone
We trust reviewers to provide comments that are both honest and respectful. Thoughtful feedback not only helps authors but also nurtures the global scientific conversation. Even when recommending rejection, frame your comments in a way that reflects professionalism and encourages the author’s continued efforts. Avoid harsh or dismissive language; be as generous with guidance as you are critical with analysis.
Confidentiality and Trust
Every manuscript you review has been entrusted to you in confidence. Please do not share, discuss, cite, or use the content for any personal purpose. The peer review process is rooted in mutual respect—between authors, editors, and reviewers—and that respect includes discretion. Should you recognize the author or suspect a conflict, you are encouraged to inform the editor immediately.
Timeliness and Communication
We understand that reviewers lead busy academic lives. If you need more time, or if the topic lies outside your expertise, please notify the editorial team as early as possible. Accepting a review implies a professional commitment—generally within 2 to 3 weeks. Your punctual response helps us maintain an efficient and respectful publication process.
Reporting Concerns Ethically
If you encounter issues such as plagiarism, data fabrication, or ethical misconduct, please raise your concerns privately with the editorial office. You are not expected to investigate, but your insights help us ensure that only credible, ethical work moves forward in the publication process. AAC treats all such concerns with confidentiality and seriousness.
Final Words of Appreciation
Peer review is often unseen but essential. Your time, expertise, and careful reading are deeply valued by our editorial team and by the authors who rely on your feedback. If you ever feel uncertain about your role or need additional guidance, please don’t hesitate to reach out.
Contact for Support
For help with your review assignment or to discuss a concern, contact our team at [email protected].